Skip to main content

6 posts tagged with "hnt earnings"

View All Tags

How To Troubleshoot Your Helium Hotspot

· 7 min read
Nik
Site Owner

Helium is a rapidly growing and wild ecosystem. Like any other new ecosystem, things are constantly changing, and the main sources of information most new users rely on (Explorer and the Helium app) can be up 48 hours behind.

That means when you check your Hotspot via Explorer on Tuesday, you could be looking at Sunday's information when it comes to whether or not you're relayed, or whether your Hotspot is online.

This isn't because Helium lnc likes to be slow, it's because the whole thing is so popular and grew so fast that the reporting side of things hasn't caught up yet. That, by the way, is a very non-technical explanation. The actual explanation is deeply technical. In any event...what do you do when your Hotspot stops working?

What I've found with hotspots over the course of consulting sessions with hundreds of clients and moderating the official Helium Discord since last spring is 2 main facts:

  1. If you have a problem, you're probably not alone. There IS a solution or at least an explanation, you just have to find it.
  2. If you haven't made any adjustments and your hotspot suddenly goes offline, the absolute best thing to do is wait, usually 48 hours.

With all that said, if you're absolutely driven to do SOMETHING because your hotspot is having problems, here are a few resources to use as you get it sorted out.

Helium Power User Superpower #1

First, and this isn't what you want to hear, but patience is a superpower when it comes to Helium. If you have your hotspot plugged into power and an ethernet cable (NOT on WiFi), your next best step to earn maximum HNT is probably to go fishing for a week. That's not the way most of us are used to solving problems, but if you've got a production hotspot and you haven't changed anything, there's not a whole lot to do.

If you DID change something (swapped the antenna, moved the hotspot, reasserted the location, etc), use Superpower #1.

Helium Power User Superpower #2

Second, about the only thing you CAN do is open up the port on your router that makes sure your hotspot can talk to the Helium Network. That port is 44158. There are a few thousand pages on the internet at this point devoted to telling you how to open port 44158 for your Hotspot.

Helium Power User Superpower #3

Third, the "Search" box on the Official Helium Discord is probably the single most useful thing you can use. Are you "unable to initiate a session" when you try to use Discovery? Copy/paste that phrase into Discord search; you'll find the latest on what's going on.

Helium Power User Superpower #4

Fourth, the second most useful thing after the Search box on Discord is probably @BFGNeil's HeliumStatus tool. It runs $2/month to use it, at least as of March 2022.

Helium Power User Superpower #5

As of mid-March 2022, we are starting to see an enormous growth in apps that help you understand the Helium Network. Here are some of my faves:

  • Watchium - Keep track of your Hotspot status and get basic info on what's gone wrong
  • Hotspotty - Track your fleet and get alerts when a Hotspot goes down
  • Helium Analytics - Keep an eye on where you are in the relation to the global average.

What About The Gamers?!

Finally, a word about gamers, cheaters, hackers and other of those ilk. In general, they're usually not worth it for the average Helium user to pay attention to. Sure, they're getting sexy daily HNT earnings or they have an obviously cheating deployment pattern, but for the most part the Helium team is shutting them down quickly or limiting what they earn. Gaming WAS a huge problem; the Modesto cluster back in late summer of 2020 was exhibit A. Now gaming is an annoyance and distraction, but not really a network problem.

Helium is made up of some of the smartest people I've met; they are NOT unaware that gaming exists, they're working hard to eliminate it, they're very capable, and they have plenty of other things to do that are equally important when it comes to the health of the network.

Rules For Helium Mining Success

At the end of the day, your "job" as a Helium deployer is to take care of what's in your control. Keep your Hotspot connected to power & internet by cables (do NOT use WiFi). Get the antenna high, use a thick enough antenna cable to limit loss, and make sure your antenna is providing WUPU (wide, unique, proveable, and useful) coverage. That's how you'll earn the most.

This shit ain't complicated, it's just hard.

If you need further help with optimizing your hotspot, read through the rest of this blog or join the Gristle Crüe!

We've helped some of the highest earners on the Helium Network go from zero to hero, and we'd love to walk you through how to maximize your Helium opportunity.

Rock on!

Archived Comments

Charles Davis - 11/22/2021

I'm waiting for my miner. From the manufacturer (being patient). Your overview was very stout with fundamental advice that I could grasp. I was about to over-supply on antenna use. Your zen about patience found a home with me, I will keep that in mind. Thanks for the steady hand.


Nik - 11/23/2021

Right on Charles. Patience is a superpower in the world of Helium.


Spencer - 11/25/2021

Brand new to this game. Day one my Nebra Outdoor was working great with decent earning. Day 2 and onward it’s not connected to network. If it connected via Ethernet port to the router and worked for a day , would the router just quit working? Eth ports work for other devices, just no longer my Nebra hotspot.


Nik - 11/25/2021

Hi Spencer, what is the Nebra diagnostic tool telling you? Have you checked out the interview I did on BFGNeil's HeliumStatus.io? Goes beyond the relay issue and into troubleshooting. Nebras in particular can be a PITA. Carefully check all the physical connections in the box; they can be loose. Also look up the Nebra light patterns and what they're telling you.


Spencer - 11/25/2021

Thank you. I will start with the video. Just perplexing as it was working and now not. Lights all good with exception of blue flashing 4x telling me no network connection. The real beauty of this is the hotspot is at a relatives and now quite a distance from me. I did try to run a diagnostic check but couldn’t connect to the unit via Bluetooth.


Nik - 11/25/2021

Just went through the same thing with a client (4x blue flash). Make sure that port is open on your network, then test with Neil's tool. Do not use Explorer or the App for up to date info.


Spencer - 11/27/2021

Hi Nik, I have tried to reach out through the contact link on this page. It keeps telling me that my message isn’t delivered. I would like to discuss your services for what I hope is basic but just not basic enough for me. Thank you


Nik - 11/27/2021

Hi Spencer, that's odd, I've received & replied to a bunch of your emails. You can email me directly at [my first name, spelled correctly (no "c")], then @ and this website. Maybe your email provider is blocking my replies? Alternately, you can just order the Hotspot Rescue Service here.


macbannai - 12/24/2021

So far all my deployments are using WiFi and it struck me when you suggested on your deliverance video that wifi is disastrous, perhaps you can elaborate on why WiFi is so disastrous other than an obvious low bandwidth scenario, for example what if wifi signal isn't an issue?


What Does A Good Hotspot Cluster Look Like?

· 10 min read
Nik
Site Owner

40-60 Hotspots, all about 1,500m away from any other, with any one of 'em having clear line of sight to at least 30 others.

Wait, you want more, and you want to know how I came up with that (with help)? Start by reading my post on PoC cycles, otherwise you'll be missing some key points. Done? Great!

Let's start with the worst case for HNT earnings: You're a lone wolf Hotspot, with no Hotspots within tx/rx distance. You can't Witness, so you miss out on 75% of available earnings. Even with a few Hotspots around you, the odds that any of your Hotspots will Beacon and initiate the larger part of the earnings cycle is low. Short version: You're not going to earn very much.

The next worst case is the opposite. You're surrounded by thousands of other Hotspots who are overcrowding the hex density rules and no one is earning very much because all your earnings are scaled. Again, you're not going to earn very much.

Ok, so now we've established the "my porridge is too hot" and "my porridge is too cold" sides. Where's the happy medium?

For help with wading through the data, I turned to the #gigs-and-bounties channel on Discord, though Helium.Jobs is another great option for getting help with anything Helium related. In this case, the folks over at LongFi Solutions responded to my request and we started into it.

Let's start with my hypothesis (which was wrong, by the way). Here's a decent way of thinking about it, it was just missing enough data points.

https://youtu.be/GtwO3EoJzPY

I thought the minimum number of hotspots you'd need in order to reliably witness beacons and therefore earn the majority of PoC rewards, would be around 300, just like Albuquerque. Here you can see the 24 average HNT earnings for any given res 8 hex using HeliumVision.

The average monthly HNT earnings of a Hotspot in Albuquerque is around 14 HNT. That may not sound much, but it's higher than anything else I could find, by a lot. I spent some time centering the map in Hotspotty on cities and seeing how many hotspots were there as well as average earnings.

It's a fast (well, slow because you're asking the map for a TON of info) and dirty way to get a "broad strokes" overview, although as you'll see, it allows you to miss some important points. Here's what I jotted down.

[ninja_tables id="2507"]

I figured that was a good start, but knew I should probably ask around for help with data that was a little more carefully assessed and parsed. Plus, where was the gold?

Where were the best spots in the country to deploy, and how many Hotspots do you REALLY need? Teling me that San Francisco is not a good place to deploy a Hotspot really isn't that helpful.

So, here's what the folks LongFi Solutions found when they dug in to my question.

What is that saying? What the heck is it? On the Y axis is the 30 day average of HNT earnings per Hotpots. On the X axis is the number of Hotspots in the city. We're zooming in progressively on each graph.

Caveats: I asked for the data on the top 500 US cities. I know, I know, I'm not a statistician. There are probably a ton of things you could get wrong by misinterpreting the data, and among the things not accounted for (off the top of my head) we're missing topography and signal strength/data size (spreading factor) changes around the world. Still, a few interesting points popped out.

Wait, you want to play with this data yourself? Cool, please share what you find here so we can all learn more! Download the data here, it's a 32 MB file, just FYI.

Here are my takeaways:

  • You probably need at least 40 hotspots to be earning well.
  • 40 hotspots isn't a guarantee, it's just a reasonable target.
  • Once you get beyond 300 hotspots, it's not that you can't earn, it's that avg earnings are low, which is important for fleet deployers.

Here are additional takeaways from the LongFi Solutions crew (specifically, @the-wildcard on Discord)

  • It's interesting to see how things converge as you move to the right, I guess it's to be expected though
  • With the pace of new hotspots coming online, a lot of these numbers include hotspots that haven't earned yet. Will revisit in a week or 2 to see what's changed.
  • Most interesting to me was that the cities with the highest average earnings per hotspot have 40-60 deployed, a little lower than what I'd expected would be needed to maximize

A few additional points are worth mentioning. Remember, I was looking for best areas, not necessarily the best locations. Locations are straightforward: Get the thing high with clear line of sight and view to lots of Hotspots. Area is harder; how many Hotspots do you really need?

Now we're all one step closer to finding out. If YOU are a data geek and would like to contribute, please let me know what you're thinking in the comments, I'd love to include you in the collective wisdom!

If you'd like to join a group of like-minded individuals when it comes to learning about and optimizing Helium deployments, check out the Gristle Crüe!

Until next time, rock on!

Archived Comments

KH - 10/13/2021

Thanks for this.. But did you forget about the reward witness scale and HIP 15 in your throughts?


Nik - 10/13/2021

Not so much forgot as "didn't include". Working with fleet deployments lately, they need to start "big picture" and once they find a likely place, explore further.


Brad - 10/13/2021

Hi Nik, Can you clarify: "You probably need at least 40 hotspots to be earning well, and by earning well I mean as of Oct 12th an avg monthly HNT earning of 14 or above." Does that mean you need to be WITNESSING at least 40 hotspots to be earning well? If so, is that measured by the number of "recently witnessed" hotspots in Helium Vision? Some of my stats: HS 1: 15 recently witnessed. Earning .39 HNT per day HS 2: 25 recently witnessed. Earning .53 HNT per day HS 3: 28 recently witnessed. Earning .28 HNT per day HS 4: 15 recently witnessed. Earning .25 HNT per day Those are all in a metro area with around 150 other hotspots. There are no other hotspots in the same hex as mine at resolution 8. All have other hotspots in some of the adjoining hexes. All are at rewards scale 1. HS 1 & 4 witness the same number of hotspots but their earnings are significantly different. HS 3 witnesses more that HS 2 but makes significantly fewer HNT. I know it's more complicated that just witnessing hotspots, but what would be causing these differences if the number of witnessed hotspots is 75% of the rewards and what can I do to improve rewards? These are all Bobcats with the stock antenna inside a single pane of glass. I'm planning on changing to outdoor antennas 15-20 feet higher than they all are now. I assume this should increase rewards significantly, or is there more I should do? Thanks!


Nik - 10/13/2021

Hi Brad, 40-60 is just a starting point. Take a look at the scatter plot graphs to get an idea of where the avg earnings in a cluster of 150-ish is. Getting your antenna outside and higher almost always increases rewards. Rock on!


Shaggy - 11/30/2021

HEY so thanks for all the great info. good pictures. And answering so many questions all the time. My biggest hang up right now is what cellular modem to use I see the rut used a lot which I read it has option to use VPN on it. Are you guys using them? Because without having a static ip address which not all cell providers have them... so does VPN keep it from being relayed? Then what type of sim are u using what brand and is it unlimited or special iot m2m type or just a cheap 20 or 30 dollar unlimited data talk text with or without static and what brand? Anyone with a handful of set up on cell modems using a family plan let me know please.


Nik - 11/30/2021

No worries Shaggy, check over here for the latest on the 240 setup.


Bronson - 2/22/2022

Question? ... 40-60 in what size of an area? In the article, you did it by cities, but what does that mean area or hex-wise?


Nik - 2/22/2022

Depends on local topography. 40-60 that can *generally* see each other seems to work well, although lately I've seen clusters as small as 20 where at least one Hotspot was up in the .2 HNT/day (double the global avg).


Gábor - 4/1/2022

Hi Nik! I live in a quite hilly area and I found a good spot which isn’t scaled and the nearest hotspot is 30km away with no line of sight. I was thinking about placing 5-6 hotspots in that hilly area among villages which have line of sight of each other. Do you think like 5-10 hotspots will be enough to earn very well if they all see each other? Thank you for your help!


Nik - 4/1/2022

Hi Gábor, that's along the lines of what the Network is looking for (correctly placed proveable coverage) but with 5-10 you may not have as many beacons issued as you'd need to earn maximally. I'd think about how you use the Network as part of the ROI plans.


What Does PoCv11 Mean For Me?

· 26 min read
Nik
Site Owner

Short version: Use a low gain antenna, report your location and antenna gain accurately. If you're in the US, this isn't a big deal, as our radios pump out enough power to get excellent range even with a low gain antenna. If you're in a region (UK, EU, etc) where your radio output is low, PoCv11 will probably decrease your range significantly.

Updated Deep Dive over here.

Want to read on for posterity? Cool!

PoCv11 is designed to help the Network more accurately assess location from radio frequency strength signals and to keep Hotspots in RF regulatory compliance. It cleans up a few mistakes Helium made early on in trying to assess radio signal strength in an attempt to combat gaming.

That's it. If you are accurately reporting your antenna gain and your location, there's no penalty and nothing else you need to do.

Normally I love to explain complicated things, but this one is so damn simple it's hard to do better than Amir Haleem, CEO at Helium:

i'll try and summarize what PoC V11 does:

adds regional support for PoC - today the network treats all PoC activity as if it's operating in the US. this is a problem as different regions run on different radio frequencies and at different power levels (by law), so what is considered valid or invalid varies substantially. V11 adds regional awareness based on the asserted location of the Hotspot

removes SNR from the validity checks - today both the signal-to-noise ratio and free space path loss calculation (FSPL) is used to determine whether PoC packets are valid or not. this was an attempt to make it more difficult for gamers to lie about their location. it hasn't worked well and is being removed. SNR proved to be fairly useless as a mechanism, so now only an FSPL calculation is used to determine whether Hotspots are where they say they are in relation to each other

adds a regional frequency check - V11 introduces a check to make sure that PoC packets are being sent at the correct frequency for the region the Hotspots are located in. for example if a Hotspot is transmitting packets in the US frequency bands but based in South Korea, those packets would now be invalid

complies with local power output regulations - different regions have different maximum power output laws for unlicensed radios. in the US, for example, the max EIRP is 36dBm. in the EU this is 16.5dBm. currently in PoC v10 the power output is hardcoded to 27dBm for the US and rest of the world, and 14dBm for the EU. V11 will reduce the power output if the combination of the maximum output power + antenna gain exceeds the local laws - for example, a Hotspot operating in the US with a 5.8dBi antenna would have a total EIRP of the Hotspot power output (27dBm) + the 5.8dBi antenna = 32.8dBm total EIRP, which is below the 36dBm allowed. nothing would change in this case. if instead the antenna was changed to a 10dBi antenna bringing the total EIRP to 27dBm + 10dBi = 37dBm, the miner software will reduce the power output of the Hotspot by 1dBm so that the total is less than equal to the 36dBm allowed by law. in the EU a 5.8dBi antenna would cause the Hotspot power output to be reduced to 10.7dBm so that the total EIRP is 16.5dBm

PoC V11 does not have anything to do with the 10 witness maximum, or the witness randomization changes that were added recently. we're hoping to activate PoC V11 in early October. it is currently not active.

But, but, but, it COSTS MONEY to state my antenna gain! Relax, dawg. It costs 55,000 DC. That sounds like a lot. It's not.

1 DC = $. 00001. So, 55,000 x .00001 = $.55. You can afford that.

I know you want to get all worked up about PoCv11 and how it will change things. Relax, it's not a big deal as long as you're playing by the rules. It's part of Helium's efforts to improve the network. Color within the lines (report your location, antenna gain, and elevation accurately) and PoCv11 will only make things better.

Archived Comments

David - 10/15/2021

Without sounding critical, it's important that people understand that the above relates a lot more to the US, in the UK where a good set up, LMR400 cable, roof mounted several metres above your house with good line of sight will still see a RAK 5.8 reach 4-5 hexes if you're lucky due to the already reduced power (I have 24 hotspots in a variety of environments running and have tried multiple antenna in multiple locations for weeks at a time so have a little experience) spending money on a decent 8 DBI makes a huge difference in HNT earnings here, and there's a strong feeling that those in the EU are getting hit hard for spending hundreds on a good set up, whilst most US users aren't bothered so the "don't worry" comments are from those likely to be based in the US and therefore unaffected - an "I'm alright Jack" attitude and I'd suggest an emphasis in the your writing that it's a US focus only. There's also a lot of confusion on Discord as to whether the reduction in power is only temporarily applied at the point of broadcasting a beacon and the full strength of the antenna is still available the rest of the time, or if its applied for both broadcast and receive.


Nik - 10/15/2021

Great points David, thanks for bringing 'em up!


Jonathan Pampers - 10/18/2021

Correct me if I am wrong, but surely those in the EU (or other countries with a lower EIRP level) can't really grumble about Helium lowering power outputs so that they are within legal levels? If the long-term growth of the network is what people want, surely hundreds/thousands of hotspots operating over legal levels in a country is a good way to go about getting it banned?


David - 10/20/2021

Hi Jonathan While I agree its got to be legal, the main issue is commercial viability- if no matter what you did your hotspot could only reach 2 RES 8 hexes, and required a good roof mount to get even that, would the current reward structure justify its long term viability and would that provide effective coverage to build the network that is envisioned? If you're looking at a European population nearly 2.5X that of the USA, then it's vital for global growth that it works effectively here, and if it is reduced, then compensation has to be increased per hotspot for people to continue to invest in the boxes and grow the network - if after POC11 a US box with a 5.8 can reach 6 miles and a European box with the same antenna can reach only 2 after it's power is reduced (which is what you currently might see with a standard 1.2 DBI here if very lucky) then assuming circular coverage you're looking at a massive difference in coverage per hotspot - 13 square miles vs 113 square miles and a massive difference in rewards earned. For HNT to work and increase in value over time you need to see continued increased global coverage, people just won't continue to invest in boxes in Europe if it isn't financially beneficial to the buyer here, destroying the HNT value for US owners.


Jonathan Pampers - 10/21/2021

I agree with you there David. From the southeast asian perspective, we have similar EIRP limits to the EU, and whilst the economic disparity between SEA and the USA might still be enough incentive in the short term, there does need to be an effective long-term incentive for people to establish good coverage.


Mario - 10/21/2021

@David, thx so much for your thoughts! You're completely right. Got my bobcats on September 7th (2 months late) to Croatia (EU) and been struggling ever since to catch up. 8 bobcats, extra taxes, LMR-400, outdoor rooftop setups, poe, splitters, solar panel, LifeP04 batteries etc. for one off-grid, >300 hours of work & troubleshooting. Not too cheap, especially cuz 75% of the stuff I needed to order from outside of Croatia... If I count in the hours spent, well, the ROI is... lets just say underwhelming. Averaging 0.3 HNT per miner with shifting to WUPU mindset isn't what I expected but still pushing through and struggling. At least for now (honestly). Or maybe I'm doing something wrong but still haven't figured out what... For example, Slow Hotpink Camel has >90 witnesses. Discovery >110. Not relayed, port open, ping-ok. rooftop, RAK antenna, 2 feet LMR400 cable... Yet, in the last days it's made 1.426 HNT TOTAL. Thats 0.2 average a day. I mean seriously wtf, some on first floors or indoors make that much. I just don't think its fair because in comparison to others with (worse or same no. of witnesses etc.) its way less. If only someone can point me in the right direction. @gristleking? :) Anyway, enjoy the rest of your days people and good luck to us on this endeavour.


Nikko - 10/22/2021

Does your general rule of thumb to place your miner location within 150m of its actual location still apply?


Nik - 10/22/2021

Yep. The closer the better, but 150m will probably continue to be fine. I mean, we won't know until after PoCv11 actually hits, but I'm guessing it'll be fine.


Vapaaherra - 11/7/2021

Hi Nik! Thanks for all the great content regarding Helium mining! A question from a European reader concerning PoC v11: is 3 dbi & more power from the hotspot equal to, say, 5.8 dbi & reduced power from the hotspot in the EU, or is there going to be a benefit in the future to use a higher gain antenna in the EU? Is it still going to provide longer range and/or different shape of the radio “donut”?


Nik - 11/8/2021

Vapaaherra, as I understand it, all hotspots in a region will be transmitting at equal power once PoCv11 goes into effect, as long as the hotspot owners accurately enter their gain into the app. Now, I'm sure that a bunch of people will either forget to update or will try entering various other numbers outside of what they're doing in an attempt to connect with more local hotspots. I'm not sure how that will work out, other than accuracy within a dB or 2 is probably close enough. That's just a guess though. We're all pretty darn curious about how it'll pan out. Here in the US I'm just going to use a low gain antenna (3 dBi), report it accurately and see what happens.


Volkan - 11/9/2021

What is the implication for the UK then? If I have understood this correctly - we are currently, even with stock antennas, broadcasting over the legal limit. With PoC v11 we will see the overall signal strength reduced to be just under the 16.5dbmi that is allowed (as I understand it the changes will hard code attenuation to deliberately NOT equal but just undershoot the legal limits) Will this mean we see reduced network coverage due to signal throttling? Will this result in a different outcome / rebalancing of transmit scales in hex's due to reduced signal strength? From the outside it seems like a change that will barely affect the US but will have quite big implications in the UK / EU


Nik - 11/9/2021

That appears to be an accurate assessment. I don't think we'll see a rebalancing of transmit scales, although that's a very interesting idea to apply regionally. Write a HIP up!


Dizzy - 11/10/2021

I dont know how it is in the Europe and other countries but US citizens have a lot of power and control on our governments rules. Perhaps there is method to voice the antenna power limit so low?


Mark - 11/13/2021

Thanks King for sharing your experience. When setting antenna gain, should the dbi losses via antenna cable length and connections be factored in for accuracy?


Nik - 11/13/2021

Yep. Remember, they're trying to measure what will be received, which will include your gain & loss from antenna, cables, connectors. Prolly not a huge deal to be off by 1 dBm, so if you're not engineer-accurate no big deal.


Why My Helium Mining Profitability WENT DOWN?! - 11/21/2021

[…] Gristle King POCV11 review – https://gristleking.com/what-does-pocv11-mean-for-me/ Check the current status of the Helium network – […]


Ethan - 11/30/2021

Hey Nik, As of today (11/30/2021), with SNR being removed from the calculation and leaving only RSSI, do you have the RSSI limits that would make a witness event 'invalid' or 'valid'. See the following link for the previous POcv10 SNR vs RSSI limits graph. Let me know if the link doesn't work. https://ibb.co/8PZ7gk4


Nik - 11/30/2021

I don't think we've moved to PoCv11 yet Ethan, so the old chart is still in play.


Jay - 12/11/2021

I have a 6dbi with 30' feet of lmr400. I input it at 5.8 because I know there is some loss with 30' of cable. Not sure if I did it right but I guess will see on Monday.


Nik - 12/11/2021

Technically that amount of cable loss will be 1.4 plus your connectors, so you're closer to 4.6, maybe 4.5.


Renas - 12/13/2021

Hey Nik, great post. Will pocV11 regulate power in both transmit and receive or just transmit? Are the power limitations only dependant on what antenna gain you input in the app or can Helium detect your actual power? If it is merely dependant on what you input in the app, could you not in theory still use a 8 dBi and input 3 dBi in the app in an attempt to not get your power limited? Thanks in advance!


Nik - 12/13/2021

Hi Renas, PoCv11 evaluates signals on both sides, transmit and receive. If you put in an inaccurate number, the further that number away is from reality, the more likely you'll have an invalid witness event. Remember, power DOUBLES every 3 dB. If you use an 8 dBi and input 3, your antenna will both sending and receiving an additional 5 dB, which is almost quadruple (2 x 2) what it "should" be. As long as you accurately report your setup, there's no further action required. As far as I know, there's no way to detect if you're accurately reporting or not other than the submitted reports. Helium can't detect what your actual power is, just what's being reported by your miner.


Stan - 12/13/2021

I am in UK. Following Niks advice I got HNtenna's for my 2 hotspots and I reach hotspots 60km away. That is a lot more than 4 hexes. I also get far better rewards than most around me and a noticeably better at receiving transmissions than many who appear to have higher gain antenna up higher than mine and reaching 80 to 100kms on transmit. Just get an HNtenna !!


Nik - 12/13/2021

Thanks for the report Stan, glad it's working well for ya!


Dennis - 12/15/2021

Hello, Love your content, thank you! Quick question... do we need to reset our location and pay the fee also or do we just resubmit the Antenna and dbi gain using the wallet app?


Nik - 12/15/2021

Shouldn't need to reassert your location (unless you actually move your hotspot). Just make sure your gain is reported accurately and you should be fine. :)


anders - 12/17/2021

What is the benefit of having a higher gain antenna in EU when the power signal is getting limited so much? If I compare using a 8 dbi antenna and the power gets reduced to match the power of a 3 dbi antenna, wouldn't it always be better to use a 3 dbi antenna in all cases since the power signal would be the same anyway? Also, the 3 dbi antenna would cover a bigger beam path than the 8 dBi. So using a 8 dBi you would lose coverage AND signal strength with pocv11. Is this correct or am i misunderstanding this? Thanks Nik.


Nik - 12/17/2021

I think you're accurately assessing the situation. I don't see a benefit to a higher gain antenna in the EU (or almost anywhere). There are exceptions, for sure, but in general a low gain antenna up high & outside will earn the most for any given location.


Rob Irwin - 12/18/2021

Thank you so much for all the advice you put out here and on Youtube Nik, my knowledge of helium mining has accelerated so quickly since discovering your site. Could you help me with a specific bit of advice regarding POCv11 and the UK/EU please? I have an indoor nebra currently with an 8dbi nebra antenna, 6 meters of LMR-400 cable and a lightning arrestor. Now that POCv11 has kicked in does this mean my Nebra is throttling the output to a full 4.1dbi and taking into account the loss for the cable and arrestor or would the antenna now be something like 3dbi due to cable and fitting losses? Secondly, does this throttling effectively change the signal pattern of the 8dbi antenna to look more like a 3dbi antenna or would it stay narrow and long, just weaker? I'd like to know if its worth the effort to change to a 5.8dbi or even lower dbi antenna. I'm in a remote location you see and there aren't many other hotspots around which is why I have been using the 8dbi.


Nik - 12/18/2021

Hi Rob, the Nebra won't throttle anything, but Helium will depending on what you enter into the app. Take the antenna gain, subtract the cable/connector loss, and enter that into the app. Cable loss won't change the pattern, it'll just weaken the signal throughout that pattern.


Mario - 12/19/2021

Hi Nik. You said it’s not a big deal as long as I'm playing by the rules... but in my case it's a huge deal. PoCv11 did the opposite for me (getting 20 invalids that I didn't have before) and earnings down "clipped" by 60% (round vanilla dragonfly). Everything asserted correctly, 3dbi McGill antenna gain - 3m(10ft) LMR-400 Times Microwave cable (0,384 loss) - Times Microwave arrestor (0,2 loss) - 0,1 for connectors = 2,316 dbi asserted. High up overlooking the city. Was making 0.7 HNT before PoCv11, now down to 0.25. Any suggestions what to do, please...? (EU located, Bobcat 2GB, RUT240)


Nik - 12/19/2021

Hi Mario, interesting that you're doing everything "right" and your earnings went down. My *guess* is that your invalids are coming from nearby hotspots who haven't updated their antenna gain, which will change the reported values into the involid zone. That's just my guess. It's an off grid?


Stefan - 12/20/2021

Nothing actually changed since POCV11, my hotspot is 150m away from the real location and my antenne dbi is 5 instead of 4. So POCV11 isn't a big deal....


Nik - 12/20/2021

100%, thank you Stefan!


Hi - 12/23/2021

Hi everyone :) one question. Where did 16,5 dbm came from when in Europe MAX EIPR = 25mw and this is 14 dbm. In that case we cannot use any antenna or I missing someting?


DimmiD - 12/28/2021

Hi Nik! I understand, that PoCv11 reduces the power of the transmitted signal. But what does mean " PoCv11 evaluates signals on both sides, transmit and receive" for the receiving side? Is the receiving (the witnessing) miner applying its antenna gain mathematically to the physically measured RSSI? Best Regards! Dimmi


Nik - 12/28/2021

The final "number" used to assess antenna signal strength takes into account both the gain on the tx side and the sensitivity (gain) on the rx side.


Matthew Yim - 12/30/2021

I bought the RAK 8dbi antenna from them direct and it comes with a 3ft cable but they don’t specify the type of cable it is. I recently just switched from a 5.8 dbi and I noticed my earnings decreased by about half, that is after a day of increasing by 15%. What should I put in for the antenna gain in my settings? Lastly, I’m in the suburbs (ASHBURN, Va, USA) and my miner is 9 meters up on the second floor window with a decent view outside. Do you think 5.8dbi would be better? Regardless both antennas came with cables that were no specified so I don’t know what to put for the gain?!? What’s a ballpark I should put because I have just been putting the antenna gain.


Nik - 12/30/2021

A day isn't long enough to make a good decision. You're fine to just put 5.8 in the app, though if you want, you can account for cable loss. I don't think it'll make a huge difference.


Matthew Yim - 12/30/2021

Thanks nick but from what I have specified do you think 5.8dbi or 8dbi is better?


Matthew Yim - 12/30/2021

Also when I compare the same hotspot that I witness, I am trying to compare the RSSI and SNR values. Is a better signal a lower negative number for RSSI and a higher more positive number for SNR?


Nik - 12/30/2021

Best to test it, but for now, read this.


Matthew Yim - 12/30/2021

Will do thanks! But could you address my final question? I have been comparing the witness transactions between the same beaconer (5.8dbi antenna vs 8dbi antenna). I noticed that while the RSSI values are LESS NEGATIVE for the 8dbi, for the most part, and the SNR is MORE NEGATIVE (these are in comparison to the 5.8dbi). Does a LESS NEGATIVE RSSI such as -101 vs -103 mean a stronger signal? Also, in terms of SNR, is a MORE NEGATIVE SNR better, such as -5 vs 5? Thank you!


Nik - 12/30/2021

Yes, -101 is stronger than -103. Totally worth reading this article on RSSI & SNR as it relates to Helium.


Why My Helium Mining Profitability WENT DOWN?! – PennsylvaniaDigitalNews.com - 1/9/2022

[…] Gristle King POCV11 review – https://gristleking.com/what-does-pocv11-mean-for-me/ Check the current status of the Helium network – […]


Mark Hallworth - 1/22/2022

Hello Nik, thanks for the great posts as usual always very informative, not sure if you remember me i was getting the RAK 5.8dbi antenna on a 10ft pole, its been doing really well, just to let everyone know it witnessed a beacon 189km away which is approx 116miles i was gobsmacked, so pocv11 doesnt seem to reduce or limit the receiving side of the antenna, ive also sent a beacon myself 109km so pretty good stats, it can also witness local hotspots to me, this is on 9metres of lmr400 mcgill microwave cable, i havent added the loss yet but i will be doing, i do have a question, would i benefit from trying an 8dbi, as some hotspots im witnessing are also being witnessed in red areas which affets rewards, so was looking to go even farther away to green areas so they are less prone to send a beacon to those red ones. Cheers.


Nik - 1/22/2022

Right on! No need to go to an 8 dBi, you typically won't see a huge difference in range when you go up in dBi with LoRa. Higher gain is used more to punch through known obstacles. PoCv11 won't effect your gain at all on the receiving side (as far as I know), it'll just take it into account. It will, however, dial you back on the tx side if you're over the legal limit.


Terry - 2/4/2022

Hi.. from the UK here and i have been putting 3.5 for my 4db antenna with 5mtr LMR400 cable... is that correct or should i just leave at 4? Reading up through the thread it seems to suggest that helium will throttle the power and rx dependant on what is sees set, is this the correct assumption?


Nik - 2/4/2022

Hi Terry, Helium will only throttle power if your gain takes you over the legal limit.


Steve - 2/8/2022

I know someone asked above, but surely people arent going to update their antenna (EU) UNLESS they get invalid warnings. Its not a guarantee leaving a lower dbi in the app and using a higher dbi antenna will result in this, until tried. So surely people are going to try to keep a higher transmit power


Nik - 2/8/2022

That's a reasonable assumption, though I bet people will be driven more by earnings than invalid warnings. ;)


Drei - 2/9/2022

In the UK and I just got my miners. Looking around me the reward has dropped drastically. I also have 2 bobcats which I may not get to use. Is there any point getting any better antennas? I was thinking to use a 12dbi inside the loft and another 4 to 6 dbi outside mounted on the chimney, this would be with 2 different hotspots, or maybe one in the back garden, but won't be doing much for distance, maybe 50 meters max. Or just stick to 1 hotspot. if so which way? In the loft with a stronger antenna and removing around 5dbi from it? Or the external one of 6dbi or 4dbi and reporting it like you suggested at -1.4dbi.


Nik - 2/9/2022

One hotspot per location is best practice. External antennas almost always outperform ones indoors. Remember to report the EIRP, not actual cable loss. So, ANTENNA GAIN minus CABLE LOSS is what you enter into the app. If you had a 6 dBi antenna with 1.2 dB of cable loss, you'd report an antenna with a 4.8 gain. Does that make sense?


Patrick - 2/12/2022

Hi Nik, Thank you for all your great support to the Helium community! I think I read somewhere that you used to like patch/directional antenna but not after the inroduction of PoCv11. Is that true and if so why is that? Thanks a lot! Patrick


Nik - 2/12/2022

Actually, the other way around. Prior to PoCv11 they were very difficult to get to work well because you had to offset the gain. With PoCv11 in place you no longer get penalized by the additional gain. Still, you're almost always better off with an omni anyway, so there's not a huge point in using directionals.


Jacobus - 2/13/2022

As far as TRANSMITTING is concerned: In Dutch regulations I see 25 mW ERP which is 14 dBm ERP, which corresponds to 16.15 (not 16.5) dBm EIRP. EU CE certificate for Bobcat miner 300 2 GB EU version says LoRa RF power is 9.90 dBm ERP. So I would argue 14 - 9.90 = 4.1 dBm is the maximum nett antenna gain, including losses caused by cable, connectors and lightning arrestor, if I dont want my TX power to be reduced by PoCv11. As for RECEIVING: For RX a high gain could still be interesting, right? If the majority of your earnings come from witnessing (and not from beaconing) than you might consider using a higher antenna gain and accepting the possible reduction of beaconing, as long as you maximize your earnings by witnessing more other hotspots. And then of course there will be people specifying lower antenna gain then they use in reality, as long as they don't get invalid witnesses. To have "best of both TX and RX worlds". Since I try to really clear this up for myself, I was curious where you found the 16.5 dBm EIRP for Europe. Thanks!


Nik - 2/13/2022

Hi Jacobus Great question & observation, sounds like you know about this than I do. :) I'll have to dig around for the 16.5 number, that came from Amir Haleem's quote. I found the EIRP on page 27 of the LoRa-Alliance LoRaWAN Regional Parameters document. "By default, the Max EIRP is considered to be +16 dBm". If you find anything else I can improve, please let me know. Thanks for bringing this up!


John - 2/14/2022

Hello Nik! Quick question or your opinion: if our current HEX is already occupied will it be worth it to place (on the app not actually) the miner on the next HEX which is empty!? The distance is 250m from the actual location.. Thanks in advance :)


Nik - 2/14/2022

Hi John, The official line is that you should assert the location where it is. My take is that mis-asserting your Hotspot is fine within, say, 150 meters for privacy reasons. You can certainly test it out beyond that. Make sure you're checking all res and not just 8.


Hey - 3/6/2022

Hey, for example if I have 7.5 antenna and my tottal los brings me to 5.8 dbi, should I add 5.8 into application or put 3dbi in order to avoid limiting my power output? I live in EU.


Nik - 3/6/2022

If you put it lower than it is you may end up broadcasting outside of legal limits. I'd just keep it accurate and use your calculated 5.8.


Ben - 4/9/2022

Hi Nik, I am in the U.K. and installing a 6dbi mcGill optimised antenna with 32 feet of lmr600. Should I input it at 5 because I know there is some loss with 32 feet of cable. I am now thinking the LMR600 was a bad investment due to new POC rules and I should have stuck to the RG58. Do you know the DBI output of the EU Bobcat 300 miner?


Ben - 4/9/2022

Hi Nik, I have been doing some research and I don’t think the 16.5DBM for the EU is correct. Everything I have read it’s coming back at 20DBM? Can you confirm, maybe it’s recently changed in 2022. If I google what is the eirp limit Europe, I get a global list, even if I search for U.K. all comes back at 20DBM can you confirm your findings. Thanks Ben


omarov - 12/23/2022

hi man. how could I know what the best (RX/ TX DBI) is according to my installation.. any calculations or advise antenna 10dbi . lmr400 30 meter antenna 10 dbi. lmr400 5meters antenna 8,5 dbi. lmr400 20 meters. and specific calculation can assume what should I adjust my flarm booster,,,>>>??? thank you


How To Use Hotspotty To Crush

· 9 min read
Nik
Site Owner

Hotspotty started as a way for Daniel Andrade (@spillere on Discord) to manage the growing fleet of Helium Hotspots he was rolling out together with Maxime Goossens and Alexis Argent.

In the beginning we had a tiny script that would send our daily rewards to a Telegram group.

It's, uh, grown from that. :)

Let's start with a little background on the Hotspotty team. Daniel is a Brazilian born itinerant consultant trained as an electrical engineer with an interest in web design & coding. He has contributed heavily to the Helium community.

Maxime is their engineering wizard, combining a drive to solve complex problems with an ability to show you, very quickly, the useful parts of the data.

Alexis has a strong interest in open source communications and blockchain technology. He's founded 2 companies in VoIP and Wireless distribution.

They recently walked me through the latest incarnation of Hotspotty in the accompanying video (vid link at the bottom).

What is Hotspotty, and how can you use it to help you within the Helium ecosystem?

Hotspotty is designed to be an all-encompassing tool for Helium users, from owners of single hotspots out to groups running a fleet of thousands. What does all-encompassing...encompass? Let's go through the high points.

Understand the Network

First, Hotspotty helps you visualize the complex math, equations, and rules that govern the growth of a healthy Helium network. If you've ever been confounded trying to wrap your head around HIP 17 with its density target, or number of siblings, or density max rules, Hotspotty makes the whole simple to understand from the perspective of any hotspot on the planet.

screenshot of Hotspotty app showing where the edges of hexes are as well as showing where overcrowded, or problem, hexes are.

Now you can see what the edge of any hex looks like (NOT a straight line), and also very quickly see where the "problem" hexes are so you can work to clear them. If you want to dive a bit deeper into HIP 17, I've got a post written up on it over here.

Collaborate with your team

Now, let's say you work with other people to manage your Network. You might have Installers, or Hosts, or a Fleet Manager, or even a Region Manager. You can separate out all those roles into Contacts or Members, assign them labels, and give them appropriate access.

Contacts may not be internal members; they could be an installer you just want to use occasionally, or a host who doesn't need to see your whole network but does need to get paid out monthly (or however you do it, this is NOT tax advice!)

Hotspotty allows you to also have Workspace Members who DO get access to the inside track. You can add these to your Members list, invite 'em in, and let them collaborate with you.

Optimize your deployment

Ok, so once you've started building your team, how do you optimize your Helium Network deployments? By diving into the Map section of the Hotspotty app and taking a look at the various tools available. As of Sep 18th, 2021, most of the tools focus on *avoiding* bad places rather than finding the best places, but that second part is coming, and soon.

What is a "bad" place in the land of Helium? I'd define it generally in three ways:

  • Density - Local and Regional
  • Topography - Signals blocked by earth
  • Volume - Enough Hotspots to reliably connect & initiate the earning sequence

I've talked a bunch about optimizing your hotspot placement (see my Rough Guide for a deep dive), but it can be complicated to run all the numbers hotspot by hotspot.

Seeing a "bad" place on Hotspotty is as easy as opening the app, clicking on the Map section, then clicking on the Hexes tab, and if you want to see specific resolutions, clicking on the Filter button.

There's another cool feature you can use just for quick checks, and that's seeing where hotspots are too close together to have a *valid* witness (the "300 meter" rule.) Here's what it looks like when you turn on the layer in the settings cog, at the top right.

See all those line between hotspots? Every one of those indicates that those hotspots are too close to each other to be a valid witness. Neat, eh?

Collaborate with the Helium community

Now comes one of the coolest parts of Hotspotty, though it'll take all of us working together to make useful: Collaboration. Of course, you can collaborate with your internal team, and that's cool, but as Max from Hotspotty says after looking through reams of data:

What we discovered is actually quite interesting; most of the optimization is beyond your control.  Your earnings are defined by your environment.

-Max @ Hotspotty

Managing the Environment - Contacting Hotspot Owners

How do you manage your environment? By talking to other people! Hotspotty allows you to do this in a reasonably anonymous way. You can send a message to any hotspot, and if that hotspot owner ever looks at Hotspotty, they'll see someone has messaged them. They can choose to ignore it, or they can "claim" the wallet associated the hotspot the received the message and start a conversation with you.

What does it look like? Let's walk through the 4 step process.

Step 1: Identify the problem. In this case, I filtered America's Finest City (San Diego) by res 7's, then just randomly selected one to see if there was an easy fix. I mean, Hotspotty is telling me we only have to move 1 of 'em!

Step 2: Dig in and look for easy wins. In this case, there's a hotspot that right on the edge of the res 7 AND is also super-crowding another hotspot. Easy fix!

Step 3: Identify the exact Hotspot.

Step 4: Initiate contact. Be cool, offer help. Do NOT be a jackwagon! Only showing them how THEY can move to benefit YOU is NOT helping the community. :)

Managing the environment: Spawning a Discord Channel

Another rad way to invite your local crew to participate is by "spawning" a Discord channel based on a specific hex. You choose your problem hex, spawn the Discord (which will open up a new channel in the Hotspotty Discord), then rally folks into it. I've done the "rally" side by working in the much larger regional channels over on the Helium official discord and saying, "Hey, if you're in [San Diego] and want to improve our reward scale, jump on into the discussion and let's crank up earnings together, [here]!"

As an example, here's the San Diego res 4 Discord channel.

Manage payouts

Finally, you can manage payouts. The Hotspotty v1 is still alive and well for this. On v2 (which is what I've covered in this post) as of today, you can just get the correct numbers for what you need to pay out, but can't automagically make it so your wallet pays another wallet on some certain date/time, but that's coming.

Ready to dive in? Cruise over to Hotspotty and sign up to get started. Enjoy, and let's make the Helium Network radical together!

VISIT THE HOTSPOTTY WEBSITE

The full interview is over on the Toobz, or you can watch it right here.

https://youtu.be/7v19oWawO1Q

Until next time, rock on!

If you’re looking for work in the Helium ecosystem, please check out this rad project I’m a part of called Helium Jobs. You can post and find jobs there, help support the ecosystem by making it easier to connect professionally, and let the world know that YOU exist and want to help contribute within the Network. Rock on!

Archived Comments

AndyCA - 9/20/2021

Thank you. Such a useful tool.


How Do You Find The Best Site For Your Hotspot?

· 7 min read
Nik
Site Owner

Well, the race is officially on. With at least two unofficial halvings coming in the near future, it's pretty darn important right now to:

A) Get your Helium hotspot up and earning and

B) Secure the best spot you possibly can.

In the case below, this hotspot is on private property with an incredible view of both my favorite place to fly a paraglider in San Diego AND an excellent view of the southern half of San Diego county.

Wait, what? More halvings? Yep, you've got 2 coming. One from network growth (network size will probably double by the end of the year) close to 300k.

Doubling the network equals (for the AVERAGE hotspot) half the rewards. Now, that's the average hotspot, but it's best to be conservative with these calculations.

What's the second halving? 5G. IF 5G rolls anywhere near as fast as they rolled out the current hotspots, it'll chew through the "up to 35%" of HNT set aside for network data transfer.

Remember, 5G is the opposite of LoRa. LoRa is small packets/large distance. 5G is large data, small distance. 5G chews through data like I used to eat gallons of ice cream; it disappears.

The catch (and really the current "doubling") is that if the "up to 35% of" HNT for data transfer doesn't get used, it gets redistributed to PoC rewards. That's us, running regular hotspots, collecting HNT for challenging, beaconing, and witnessing. Mostly, for witnessing, but that's another story.

Since our current PoC (Proof of Coverage, more on that here) rewards account for 26% of all HNT (let's call that about a third) and the data across the network isn't anywhere near capacity of "up to 35%" (we'll call that another third) we're basically getting two thirds of all HNT distributed, which is double what we're technically earning.

So, when that data gets used up by 5G hotspots, our rewards will be halved again from today. That's the bad news.

The good news is that wherever there's challenge, there's opportunity. For you hard chargers who are willing to hustle for the love of crypto and fun new enterprises and high-risk/high-return livin', giant opportunities still abound. Let's talk about a few of 'em.

First, there's the stuff you do yourself. You can use Helium.Vision or Hotspotty or Kudzu to go deep or HotspotRF (or even Google Earth) to keep it simple. Find the high points and places where your hotspot can be placed for maximum earnings. Maybe you get fancy on Google Earth and run an altitude layer to make sure you're only looking at islands in the sky, or you re-watch the demo I did on Helium.Vision and make sure you know how to use all aspects of that super powerful tool.

A hotspot with a high volume / low density view is optimal, but even a high volume / high density view like the one below can be a high earner.

You find the spot, you figure out who owns the rights to it, you contact them, negotiate an agreement, install your hotspot, and, as my English uncle says, "Robert's your father's brother." Us Yanks are little more direct and just say "Bob's your uncle."

Hot tip? Look for land brokers. They represent empty lots of land that could use a little income. That tip came from one of my most successful clients who is also an absolute wizard marketer. He has built a marketing & sales system for Helium placements that gets a 50% callback rate on leads (unheard of!) and he cherry picks the best spots. Without giving away his location, out of the top 10 Helium hotspots in his area (a place with over a thousand hotspots), he's runs 3 of 'em. He sells that system, if you're interested in that just reach out.

Finding your own placements is one of those "most work equals most rewards" deals, but if you've got a lot of hotspots, that's a lot of work.

That brings us to your second option, a recent start-up called Sitenna.com. They connect you (the antenna/hotspot owner) with land owners. You don't look for spots, you just supply the hardware, pay the rent, and collect HNT. Obviously it's slightly more complicated, but that's the gist.

If "pay to play" is your game, Sitenna is looking to be a very promising option. Tell 'em Gristleking sent ya, it'll be good for a laugh. They're a couple of recent Y-combinator types on a trajectory to crush; we Helium peeps might as well go along for the ride.

Third, you can make your own placements. This is by far the hardest, as well as in the long run *probably* the most profitable. You go out and find a business that could actually benefit from LoRa. It'll need to meet very specific requirements: They'll want to cover a large area, they don't need a ton of data, there's a clear profit motive, and they're willing to see the world in a new way.

Whether that's a cattle rancher in Montana, a scooter operator in Cancun, a boat tour operator in Cabo San Lucas, or FedEx, well, there's a whole giant world of opportunity out there for ya, but it does wear overalls and look a lot like work.

Here's me and a buddy at the beginning of my very first off grid placement (when I thought antennas mattered), about to do a 12 mile round trip hike in the mountains carrying 60 lbs each on the way out and running out of water on the way back. That was straight work, yo.

If you're looking for help to optimize YOUR hotspot placements, whether it's the one on Mom's house or the fleet you're rolling out in a far off land, consider hiring an expert for help.

In the meantime...get 'em!

How Much HNT Will My Hotspot Earn?

· 41 min read
Nik
Site Owner

One of the most frequently asked questions in all of the Helium space is: “How much will I earn?”

Here's how to get to a reasonably accurate prediction for your location. We'll start with numbers, do some more numbers, do a little educated guessing, and end up with a conservative estimate of how much a given spot will earn.

The Global Average

Starting at the top, the global daily average for a Helium Hotspot that's online is .091 HNT/day. How did I get that? Math.

I took the share of HNT we Hotspots get monthly (26%), added in the unused HNT from Network Data Transfer, removed the Hotspots that are offline, and came up with a reasonable global average. Just in case you missed it above:

The Global Average For A Helium Hotspot is .091 HNT/day As Of March 6th, 2022.

So, is that YOU will get? On average, probably. Of course, if you're reading this blog, you're probably above average. In that case, how do we make a reasonable guess for how much YOU will make, in YOUR location. Lemme show ya:

https://youtu.be/o5uHEK6eLXg

Here's how I'd do it: Take the Global Average as my start point, see if my Regional Average is higher or lower, take a look at local res 8 hexes, decide whether or not my deployment will be above or below average, and make an educated guess off of that.

If you want help with that, try either of the Helium Courses on this site, or you can join the Gristle Crüe and jump in on weekly calls where you and a bunch of other folks into Helium can learn from me and each other on how to crush it in Helium.

Here are all my sources for this info:

  • Number of Hotspots, DC burned, HNT Price: Helium Explorer
  • Percentage of Hotspots Online: DeWi ETL
  • Number of HNT Distributed Per Month, PoC & Network Data Transfer Percentages: Helium Docs

Here are the resources used in the video:

I'll finish up with what Helium USED to be like. This was post was initially written in mid-March of 2021. I'm leaving it up mostly for historical purposes (and so some of the older comments make sense.) Rock on!


LEGACY STUFF - READ THIS IF YOU WANT TO SEE WHAT HELIUM WAS LIKE IN MAY OF 2021

Oh, the other question you'll have is along the line of: If I only have XX hotspots in my city, and I own them all, how much can I expect to earn? There are many caveats to this, mostly centering around how many of those hotspots can "see" each other. One SUPER important thing to note from these examples is that most hotspots owners do a poor job of deployment, earning on average 2 HNT/day. An optimized hotspot with good placement should earn at least 8 HNT/day. If you'd like help with doing a much better job, consider hiring me to help you maximize your earnings.

I'll give you a few real world examples of 7 day earnings. (data here, as of May 9th, 2021).

  • Flagstaff, AZ - 6 hotspots - 79.52 HNT
  • Jerome, AZ - 6 hotspots - 97.91 HNT
  • Midland, TX - 4 hotspots - 57.3 HNT
  • College Station, TX - 4 hotspots - 68.25 HNT
  • Charlottesville, VA - 4 hotspots - 46.15 HNT
  • Erie, PA - 4 hotspots - 25.89 HNT
  • Elfrida, AZ - 3 hotspots - 57.98 HNT
  • Arizona, TX - 2 hotspots - 24.67 HNT
  • Columbus, GA - 2 hotspots, 42.50 HNT
  • Three Rivers, MI - 2 hotspots - 14.26 HNT

For those of you who want to see how I come up with averages and be able to do it themselves, here’s a 10 minute video that uses Sitebot. Sitebot used to be a superb resource, but has degraded and is no longer good for this. Still, I'll leave this up so you can see the thought process.

This will show you how much HNT you should expect to earn on average, and you’ll learn how to easily refine that number for yourself, in your city.

https://vimeo.com/523620857

Before we move on, let me set some expectations. This post was originally written in mid-March of 2021. We only had 22k hotspots on the network at the time. 3 weeks later (April 5th) we had 25k. That number will continue to go up, probably to 200k by the end of the summer of 2021. Within a few weeks of it being written, all the hard numbers in this post will be wrong. Still, you can use the method in the video to calculate what the numbers *should* be for the next few weeks for you.

First, I’ll knock out my assumptions:

I’ll assume that you are NOT going to plug in your hotspot at Mom’s house and walk away. If you do that, you should expect to earn less than .1 HNT a day.

I’ll assume that you’re willing to spend money, time, and effort to optimize your hotspot placement. As in, more time than your friends and family think is “reasonable”.

As I learned long ago from Shawn Alladio (one of only two humans to ever ride a jetski over a 100' wave) if you want to do awesome things you should be unreasonable. Be like Shawn. She’s rad.

I’ll assume that you understand the general intent of Helium. Psst, it’s to provide as much useful coverage as possible for IoT devices running on the Helium network.

Finally, I’ll assume you’re not contemplating a “lone wolf” placement, which is one where there is no possible way for another hotspot to connect with you via radio signal.

Ok, with that out of the way, let’s start high. Like, way high. The top earning hotspot in the world (as of March 14th, 2021) is Rough Chili Bird, in Springdale, Arkansas. Before I tell you how much HNT they’re earning, let’s define “top earning.”

Basically, no Helium data for earnings is useful at anything less than a 7 day cycle. 24 hour, even 48 hour stats are just too variable to be useful. As an example, here are the daily earnings for a reasonably high performing hotspot.

As you can see, they vary wildly day by day, and if you constantly fiddle with it in order to improve, you’ll be responding to noise, not signal.

Helium is all about signal.

Back to the world’s highest earning hotspot, Rough Chili Bird.

The Bird earned 2,850 HNT over the last 30 days. Yeah, that’s a lot. At current HNT prices well, people work a lot harder for a lot less money per month.

Second place is Docile Bone Pony over in Cambridge MA, earning 1,787 HNT in the last 30 days. No, I don’t make these names up, and neither do the hotspot owners. They’re randomly assigned.

Here’s the top 10 earners, pulled off of Sitebot.

So that’s the MOST you’re likely to make. You probably won’t make that much. I went through a few cities (including my own, America’s Finest City) to give you some averages.

For your average hotspot, you’re looking at right around 8 HNT/day.

I got that by going through and weeding out all the hotspots making less than 1 HNT/day. If they’re doing that, it’s pretty obvious they’re not in this to crush, and that’s my goal. CRUSH.

I was curious about the crushers, so I went through the top 1,000 Hotspots in the USA and found the average was more than twice as high; about 23 HNT/day. You can reasonably expect that if you optimize density, elevation, and antenna, in that order.

I went through a few example cities (San Diego, Seattle, London, and Berlin) and then I looked for the answer to the second most popular question I get asked, which is:

“I live in a small city and could buy 5–10 hotspots right now. Should I do it? How much will I make?”

The stats are in the video, here’s the boring stuff for those of us who read.

San Diego has 142 hotspots earning more than 1 HNT/day. The average hotspot earns 9 HNT/day, and the top earner pulled in 1,334 in the last 30 days.

Seattle has 90 hotspots earning more than 1 HNT/day. The average hotspot earns 8 HNT/day, and the top earner pulled in 706 in the last 30 days.

Seattle Helium Hotspot Earnings

London has 188 hotspots earning more than 1 HNT/day. The average hotspot earns 8 HNT/day, and the top earner pulled in 1,266 in the last 30 days.

Berlin has 134 hotspots earning more than 1 HNT/day. The average hotspot earns 12 HNT/day, and the top earner pulled in 1,617 in the last 30 days.

Berlin Helium Hotspot top earner

Finally, I found a small cluster of hotspots that is typical of any small deployment in a city. It was on the south side of Cypress, in Limassol. While there are 10 hotspots deployed there, only 5 have been running for 30 days or more. Those 5 average 16 HNT/day, but the top earner only pulled in 592 in the last 30 days.

Helium Hotspots in Limassol, Cypress

This should help you get a rough idea of how much you’ll make. For more on Helium Hotspot Optimization you can read my guide over here.

If you’d like a different take on earnings with an orientation toward what might happen in the future as the network grows, check out Steve’s article over on DeWi.

Best of luck with your deployments, let’s grow this network together and CRUSH! If you’d like help with a Helium deployment, from a single hotspot to an entire ecosystem, consider hiring me.

None of this is investment advice. Keep reading and learning. You could lose everything. I hope you don’t. I hope you win so big that you track me down and plant a big wet kiss on my cheek and slip a QR code with 10 BTC into my pocket because you just have that much to spare. Here’s to your success!

Archived Comments

Mark Cobleigh - 3/18/2021

In your article about maximizing your hotspot you mentioned that we shouldn't use more than 5 feet of cable. If that is impossible, what is the max length we should run if we're using LMR400 cabling? I have a few spots that will be very high and very difficult to get to after initial install (renting a boom lift) and want to run about 50 feet of cable down to about 15 feet above ground where the hotspot will be. I hate to go through all this just to find out that 50 feet of cabling is too much. Also, I can't seem to find much information on "terminating" LMR400 wire. With regular coax I have my own tools and can run my own cabling from a spool of it. Can I do the same with LMR400? Thanks in advance, and great articles to read, best yet.


Nik - 3/18/2021

Hey Mark, I need to re-word that "5' rule". It's a good idea to keep cable as short as possible, but it's not a game-ender if you have to make a long run. That's what low loss cable is for. One of the highest earning hotspots out there uses 60' of LMR400, although that is definitely the exception, not the rule. :). 100' is probably the max length, but you're going to lose a fair amount over that length, so you'll need to offset that with antenna selection (beyond the scope of this article & comment) and elevation. To terminate LMR400 you'll probably spend about $300 in new tools, then there's the cost of the cable & the connectors. You're probably better off just getting USACoax to build you custom lengths. Here are the recommended tools from that linked video on how to terminate: CCT-02 cutting tool - $45 CST-400 prep tool - $100 CT-300/400 crimp tool - $150 Biodegradable silicon lubricant


Robert - 3/18/2021

I use 12' of LMR-400 on a 5dBi Nearson antenna and earn roughly 20HNT per day with roughly 8-10 recent witnesses. My Antenna is around 24' off the ground and on a hill with a good line of sight. I used USA Coax to get 10' and 2' LMR-400 cables connected by a lightning arrestor. There isn't really a hotspot that should be witnessing mine that isn't. To me, height and line of sight are the main factor. Having said that, I could have settled on only 5' of cable, but was concerned about making the mast top-heavy with the enclosure and hotspot mounted near the top. Wondering if you've had any trouble with wind on that super high mast in San Diego? I'm planning on setting up 3 outdoor antennas in a rural area so that they can witness each other and provide coverage to a small city of around 50,000 people. I'd like to shorten the coax, but am concerned about the top heaviness. Any tips?


Nik - 3/18/2021

Robert, agree 100% re height & line of sight; those (and correct density) are what determine the majority of earnings. Connections are a distant fourth. I guyed that pole on the mountaintop; the weather station that's also on there has recorded 58 mph gusts, and all appears to be good.


The Top 5 Mistakes to avoid with your Helium Hotspot | One man's search - 4/11/2021

[…] info. I’ve writ­ten about how to opti­mize your hotspot place­ment, which anten­na is best, how much you can expect to earn, […]


Martin - 4/12/2021

The three words for location names should be tied into the Awesome global mapping system "what3words" which is also catching on really quick. The three words identify a unique grid location on the world where people are now using it for deliveries (pizza, drone etc) and is far more precise than a traditional zip code. For instance, my location in the world is "straddled.spinning.myself". Combining Helium addresses with what3words is very logical to me.


Robert Engelbrecht - 4/16/2021

I understand the 300m hotspot separation but . . I intend installing on the roof of my 5flr condo building and we're on an escarpment in my city . So I'm wondering if I could place two hotspots ( one each on the east & west ends of the roof which is about 100m long) using two flat panel antennas backed with metal sheeting and directed 180deg opposite each other. I'm hoping this will allow me to reach the max number of hotspots in my city (Calgary, AB, Canada) and optimize my earnings. Comments ?


Nik - 4/16/2021

Hi Robert, you'll clip your own earnings by having 2 in the same hex 8, plus you may run into black box rules designed to combat gaming. Better with an omni up on a pole on the roof.


Tucker - 4/16/2021

Hey Nik Just ordered an indoor one for my apartment. Looked on the map and saw I am in a red zone with one about a half mile away. I live in Los Angeles. How will this effect my potential earnings?


Nik - 4/16/2021

Hi Tucker, Being in the red zone will clip your and their earnings, and you won't be able to witness/earn from each other. If you can find another spot outside of the red zone (assuming you're talking about Helium.Place) you'll double your earning potential.


Knut E. - 4/20/2021

Hey! I'm considering getting some hotspots, I really love the concept and all of that... But I realized that two things might limit my earnings. 1. I live far from the closest active hotspots (we're talking 325km away, they're in the capital, and I'm not) 2. There are mountains cutting my line of sight from the closest "medium" city (no hotspots there either, but I could set up one there as well, the distance from my home hotspot and the one in the city would be ~13km) Would you say this would still be worth it, or should I just drop it and move on?


Nik - 4/20/2021

Hi Knut, Probably not worth it to set up a bunch of lone wolf hotspots. If you can manage a deployment where 3 or 4 hotspots can communicate and provide useful coverage, that'll be a much better option.


jorge - 4/21/2021

Hey Nik, thanks for the write-up. Very good stuff. I'm still doing my research but leaning on the Nebra Outdoor and just pre-order now. Based on your other write-up, this would be a good way to go. Checked the coverage map around me and there seem to be a good amount of hotspots nearby. I'm in City of Miami proper, in a house, closer to the more densely populated areas, and the downtown and financial districts where there are high-rises. Still reading up, but I see one hotspot that's about 4 blocks from me, has a good amount of witnesses, and respectable earnings potential. But I see others that are not so great. I'm going to walk by there tonight to see if I can scope the aerial. I also checked helium.place and there's about 15 hotspots in the sweet spot outside the 350m radius. Seems like it could be pretty lucrative based on the earnings of this one hotspot 4 blocks away, but the earnings of the others pale by comparison. What's driving the difference? I'd like to start with one, but we have an investment property about 2.5 miles away from our primary residence that I could expand to. I have a second investment property, but that's about 12 miles away and there doesn't seem to be a lot of hotspots out there.


Nik - 4/21/2021

Jorge, the uneven earnings are probably due to what I call a "Canyons & Crags" strategy, where one hotspot can see many others that can't all see each other. The one that can see many gets earnings "focused" on it.


jorge - 4/22/2021

Interesting. Thanks for the insight. I walked around last night and could not see an aerial anywhere on that house, so I started wondering if the location assertion was correct or maybe your C&C strategy explains it. This hotspot is approx 397m from my location. And has witnesses as far as 2km out. I'm very curious about it and I wonder if I could benefit by having this hotspot right outside the invalid witness zone. https://explorer.helium.com/hotspots/11HDX56zJiVUxXWMrrXbtAbaNoSEP16TgN4jTdbY3wHBpCo9PtJ I also walked by another four that are all clustered, around 800m from my location. They look to be on the roofs of a commercial structure. All considered, seems like a good scenario to move forward with a Nebra outdoor and see where it goes. Thanks for letting me bounce ideas and would appreciate your comments on the above.


Will - 5/3/2021

Hey NIK, I live in a rural town of 1500 that has none of these. The next town over has 3hotspots . which is about 15miles away. if buy 3 or 4 of these and place them throughout town will it even be worth the time and money?


Nik - 5/3/2021

Probably. Look for sets of 3 that are isolated and check out earnings. Last time I did that it was 60 HNT/miner/month with a 3 set. Not amazing, but not bad either.


Helium, Explained (ELI5) - One Man's Search - 5/9/2021

[…] How much will I make? Short answer is from .7 to 70 HNT/day. Most of you will make less than 8 HNT/day. Some of you will earn more than 20. […]


Lisa Helser - 5/16/2021

I live in a county that has only 1 green dot, 15 miles from me. Is this worth me getting into? Thank you


Nik - 5/16/2021

Probably not if you're only going to get one and it can't connect with the other one. Best to have groups of at least 4, see The Dice 5 strategy, here.


James Cowin - 5/18/2021

Hey Nik, Couple of questions. First let me say thanks for your help and this page, lots of good info and a LOT to read so please forgive me if I am asking questions that you have covered elsewhere. I live in a third world country, who would use my hotspots? Do I have to advertise? Where does the "money" come from? There is a city in this country (where I have friends) and it has three hotspots. Would placing 3 of my own hotspots in that city (new total of 6 hotspots not in any RedZones) be better or worse than installing 3 hotspots (no others in the entire city) in my city assuming the same population density? What is the ideal spacing of hotspots on level ground? Thanks


Nik - 5/18/2021

Hi James, anyone who wanted to use IoT data could use your hotspots. Tracking, environmental variables, inventory management, etc. You'd earn HNT from the data that gets passed. You'd probably be better off adding 3 hotspots to the city that already has them. Ideal spacing on level ground is probably just meeting res 8 hex requirements, say, 600m-1km apart. Depends on a ton of variables, but that'd be where I'd start.


James Cowin - 5/19/2021

Thanks for responding so quickly Nik, As you mentioned in one of your posts, if I keep reading I will find answers, which I did, like the 600-1000 meters apart which I found. However your answer of placing hotspots in the other city surprised me. Another question which unfortunately wont really help your USA readers but may be important to those like me, living in 3rd world countries. In the USA, network speeds are in the 50-100Mbps range, however down here a basic internet connection could be as low as 3Mbps (of course there are faster, mine is 50 down/5 up) but is there a minimum required internet connection speed for a Helium Hotspot? James


Tom DAngelo - 5/23/2021

Hey Nik, Great info! Hoping to get your thoughts. I have a couple of Bobcats and am about a week in. With one of them, I am about 36ft up in an apartment. I am seeing 15 average witnesses but earning less than 1 HNT per day. I have a 9dbi coming witch I hope will help. Any thoughts on why such low earnings? Thanks. Tom


Nik - 5/23/2021

Hi Tom, probably due to a few factors, mostly around density and the amount of "unique" coverage you're providing. Have you run any RF sims over on Helium Vision? The 9 dBi may decrease valid witnesses. Have you looked at the Challenge Receipt Analysis dashboard to see if your witnesses are invalid?


Nik - 5/23/2021

There is, but it's pretty low. Bottom of this page. :)


Tom D - 5/23/2021

Thanks Nik. I have run some rf scenarios and it looked pretty good. Just ran the Challenge receipt dashboard and showed “no results” for all categories. Chilly Carrot Cuckoo Tom


Nik - 5/23/2021

Looks like you're getting scaled at .5 and providing what I think of as "one-way non-useful coverage", which is a bummer, because you're actually expanding the network. It happens when you have something out on the edge of a network that's only communicating to hotspots that all already see each other, and not "connecting" two large regions. I have a similar hotspot that I've got to move.


SEAN O CONNELL - 6/1/2021

How do I solve the hotspot `being relayed` issue using wifi ? Would Ethernet solve it and does this decrease my earnings.


Tony - 6/5/2021

Hey Nik, I live in a 3 acre farm land far away from the city. I have decided to purchase 20 helium miners and place it 300m apart from one another. Would this work in my favor?


Nik - 6/5/2021

You're going to need more than 3 acres to place them all 300m apart, plus you'll need to have it's own separate connection to the internet. Think about adding value to the network vs just providing non-useful coverage.


SEAN O CONNELL - 6/6/2021

Hi Nik, which is more useful in earning HNT - Lora end node coverage or witness proof of coverage ?


Nik - 6/6/2021

Hi Sean, for earning HNT it'll be PoC.


James Graves - 6/28/2021

Hi Nik, I am looking to buy a couple of these...I have no nodes in my area (Suffolk, VA). I am going to try buying two and putting one in my FIL's house, about 5 miles away and see what happens. If I can make money with it, I might see if I can clue some other folks in the area in to this to get some nodes built out-will just two nodes manage to get anything? Also, what do you think of building out nodes in the country? I have a lot of friends about 15 miles outside of town with several hundred acres...we could build out nodes in that area, as well-I'm just not sure if nodes out in the country serve any kind of purpose. It is just a few miles from Franklin/Petersburg/Suffolk, so-maybe?


Nik - 6/28/2021

Hi James, typically you want your hotspot to be able to see at least 4 other hotspots. That being said, having 2 is 10x better than having 1. As far as building out in rural areas, that can work well although you have to be pretty careful about distance and line of sight for pure earnings purposes. Over the long run, hotspots that are placed with an eye towards growing WUPU coverage will do the best.


MICHAEL - 7/13/2021

Hello I live in a town of 12000 with no miners. Wad looking at placing 5 to 7 around town close enough they could see each other but not closer then 800m. Would that enough to get cash back on miners in a couple months? Thanks


MICHAEL - 7/13/2021

Hello I was looking at placing 5 to 7 in my area. There are no others there could I make my money back on the miners in a couple months? Thanks


Nik - 7/13/2021

Hi Michael, it depends on what the price of HNT is when you get them, and how many miners are on the network. It's pretty reasonable (though NOT a guarantee!) that they'll pay off within a few months if they're all optimally placed.


Nicolas - 7/19/2021

Hey, i live in Dubai..i checked the helium map and i noticed that nearest hotspot is 12 Km away from my appartment..and i think im alone in the city where all the miners are in downtown dubai (14km far ) so how much i could probably make a month ?? Is it woth it?


Nik - 7/19/2021

Hi Nic, with the closest miners 14 km away I wouldn't expect top tier earnings, but it may surprise you. As far as how much per month, I don't think anyone can give any kind of accurate answer. Your best bet is to look for other miners with the same position as yours and see how they're doing, then average that out. Helium seems to pay off faster than damn near any other project I've seen, but it's not as fast today (July 19th, 2021) as it was even a month ago.


zaid - 8/1/2021

hi nick im from pakistan there are only two hotspots near my city which are almost 80km away from my city would it be worth in my city for hnt mining


Nik - 8/1/2021

Hi Zaid, probably not worth it with just one. You *might* hit them, but you're better off putting up at least 2 (and better, 5) yourself.


MacStone - 8/2/2021

Hi, I am still trying to wrap my head around how it works but, am I correct in assuming that if nobody uses the WiFi provided, you don't earn anything ?? Im just wondering as the closest to me is 25km distance and I was considering setting up 4-6 units in my town where there is nothing going on. (population of roughly 9000). Any comments/advice would be appreciated. Cheers


Nik - 8/2/2021

Nope, earnings are only partly based on the data you processed. To be clear, you're not providing "WiFi", you're providing a different type of coverage (IoT coverage via LoRa). You'll earn the most by your hotspots "talking" to other hotspots, proving that they are where they say they are. 4-6 units is a good number to earn optimally as long as they have good spacing and Line of Sight to each other.


James Cowin - 8/6/2021

Hi Nik, With respect to earnings I ran across two USA hotspots that have me thoroughly confused... sneaky-golden orca……. 40 witnesses and only 3 HNT for a month and sharp-grape-grasshopper…..zero witness and 67 HNT for a month. Obviously it happens, but could you offer an explanation as to why? Jim


Buster - 8/11/2021

I'm at the bottom of a hill my Bobcat Miner is 20 Meters up on my roof with a 8dbi antenna . I'm showing two hotspots nearby, will I be able to witness them if its showing them near by on the Coverage Map data? Its is also showing that I sent Data I transferred a data packet. my hot spot is. Restless Rosewood Cat I hope I'm not a lone wolf.


Buster - 8/11/2021

If you don't witness right away are you pretty much a lone wolf?


Nik - 8/11/2021

Hi Buster, nope, it can take time to witness. Remember, you've got to witness a beacon from another hotspot. Hotspots can beacon once a day and sometimes much less, so if you only have a few nearby you may have to wait a few days to build up your witness list.


Nik - 8/11/2021

Good news that you're transferring data packets; you're a useful part of the network! Witnessing other hotspots is a function of line of sight; if your antenna can "see" their antenna, you'll witness 'em.


Frank - 8/13/2021

Hey Nik, is there a better way I can contact you with further questions?


Nik - 8/13/2021

Hi Frank, sure, via Contact form here or if you're interested in consulting, here.


Frank - 8/14/2021

How Likely would I be able to put a hotspot on a cell tower, and where would I go to find out more info.


Nik - 8/15/2021

Hi Frank, at the base of most cell towers (or on the fence around cell tower sites) is contact info for the tower owner. Start there. You're usually better off looking up local WISPs (Wireless Internet Service Providers) and working with them. The big cell tower companies aren't really set up to do business with individuals, but WISPs are usually Mom 'n Pop shops that'll work with you.


David - 11/14/2021

Hi Nik, I’ve read a few of your articles now and I’ll just lead off by saying thank you for sharing your knowledge. I’m waiting on pre-ordered miners and simply trying to work out as many issues before I even see them delivered. I live in a relatively rural area with a small town 7 miles away and pockets of small subdivisions about 1-2 miles apart from each other. Flat terrain but lots of tall trees surrounding neighborhoods. I plan to place an additional set up at a family members house via roof top antenna. However, I’m worried about how tall I can realistically make the antenna. The home is surrounded by tall trees, approximately 70 feet tall. This property is maybe 3 miles from my home LoS. Is it worth placing a setup there based on trees? I plan to have a roof top antenna at my home, 2 story home. I’ve ordered 5.8 dbi antennas for my planned roof top rigs. I do have friends in most of the surrounding neighborhoods (1-4 miles away range) and plan to sweet talk setups at their properties as well. *Most of those have minimal tree issues.


Nik - 11/15/2021

Hi David, LoRa at 915 will go through 60-100m of dense brush, maybe more in the US with our higher output. I think you'll be fine over the short distances you're talking about, but getting your antennas high will be key.


Darius - 11/15/2021

Does level above the sea count?


Nik - 11/15/2021

Not sure what you're asking. If it's elevation for the app, nope, just your antenna height above ground.


Jonathan Libbrecht - 11/26/2021

Hello, I have received my sensecap miner a few days ago, but I have a question. I suppose that the numbers you are using here are not relevant anymore, because with an average of 8HNT/day, you would be looking at 9600 dollars a month. But what would be a good average daily number to be aiming for? (Just so you know, I am from Europe). At the moment, my choises to place the miner are: 1. in a crowded city with already 10 other miners in my hexagon. 2. around 10km (6 miles) from a big city without many miners closeby. 3. around 2km (1.3 miles) from a normal sized city but with a forest of around 150m between me and the city. Sadly, the trees are just to high to go above them. (p.s. I am currently using a 6dBi antenna) Where would you recommend me to place my miner? I really want to thank you for your time!


Nik - 11/26/2021

Hi Jonathan, yes, those numbers are long out of date. Globally, the average hotspot earns .2 HNT/day (as of 26Nov2021). None of those are good options. I'd look for other, better locations where you have better density close by.


Nicole Vada Harris - 12/3/2021

I have earned 1.992 Helium in 2 weeks. Static 1.0


Nik - 12/3/2021

That's not very much. What's your setup/location look like?


JamesD - 12/8/2021

Hi Nik, First of all, great posts, here and on other boards. I live at the edge of town out on the edge of burbs. Lot of miners 1-2 per hex through 15 miles of burbs to the north (and more in the downtown beyond that). To the south, none. Farmers. I.e. west, nw, n,ne and east have miners. Sw, s, se nada. I just got my antenna and was going to head the roof to get a little higher up. I picked up a high drive because it's flat and I want to pickup for miles. 2 questions, a) what can I do if anything with my dynamics of all the other hotspots on 1 side and b) is it worth getting up on the roof and putting the antenna up there (vs inside)? Thanks sir..let me know I'd you have unix or hadoop questions and I'll return the favor :)


Nik - 12/8/2021

I'd put an omni directional up and get it as high as possible. Now I've got to go Google hadoop. ;)


Me Smith - 12/18/2021

Hi Nik Great post. Thank you for sharing. Tart Maroon Ant here…just started but trying to leverage all I can. Ok seeing .17/day right now and just swapping to a 5.8db antenna in the roof yesterday. Is there anything else I should be doing to critique these numbers? I’m at the highest point in elevation around and there are some getting .34-.49 close by with similar setup and signal(which is .6). Any recommendations would be helpful. Thanks


Nik - 12/18/2021

Be patient. Once you lock in a location & get it high and gather 7 days of earnings data, that's going to be what you'll get unless you make a change.


Mr smith - 12/18/2021

Thank Nik Is there a way to improve transmit scale? I’m showing .60 currently. Also internet speed wise I have the best 800mbps(getting 295 wired and 80-130 wireless). Does that make a different? Would I help to add a repeater upstairs to improve the signal up there? Thanks again


Nik - 12/18/2021

Gotta move it (or others) to change scale. https://gristleking.com/hip-17-why-are-you-getting-scaled/ Better on wired connection just because it's more stable.


Brendon - 12/28/2021

Hello Mike, glamorous stone wasp here. I just deployed a nebra indoor hotspot with a 12dbi antenna I installed on the roof. House is on a hill in a densely populated city. So far my 2 day total is .6 HNT. There are 5 other hotspots in my hex. Should I do anything different. Thank you!


Nik - 12/28/2021

Yes, read through a few more articles on this blog, namely the Best Antenna and the HIP 17. :)


Shuayb Magan Barre - 12/29/2021

Hi Nik Thank you for the information and as myself I want to buy some helium miners and I will buy the course soon. I have one question can the miners work any part of the world ex Africa etc, especially undeveloped country Thank in advance


Nik - 12/29/2021

Depends on what radio bands your country allows, but they'll work in *most* places.


John J - 1/1/2022

Hey Nik, I am halfway between San Diego and LA in Southern California. I've been watching and reading so many mixed reviews. The internet full of amazing knowledge, but its hard to find the truth. Where can I find legit numbers as far as expectations go? Also, if signal strength is what matters most, how do I go about learning how to optimize signal strength? I looked at the map, and it doesn't look like anyone is in my hex. There is 2 in the adjacent HEX. Any advice is much appreciated.


Nik - 1/2/2022

Hi John, I'd start with the reading through the blog. As far as expectations, typically you'll earn the average of your closest 10 hotspots, unless you do something extraordinary. Check out the Helium Basic Course, that'll give you a bunch of good info in about an hour.


Brian T Sload - 1/2/2022

Hi, I'm in a suburban area no hex's around but I should be able to set up 3 next to each other. Another 1 mile away. Do I need people to actually run a app to mine HNT? Can u run two miners next to each other? Thanks Brian


Nik - 1/2/2022

Hi Brian, short answer: You can, but they won't earn well. You usually want at least 1,000 meters between miners. If you want to learn everything you need to know about Helium in just under an hour, I'd recommend enrolling in the Helium Basic Course.


Arlinson - 1/6/2022

So Nik if there is a suburban area and no hex's are around but I have 4 miners can I put them 300-1,000 meters apart and be able to get more HNT ? How much HNT should I be getting ?


Nik - 1/6/2022

Hi Arlinson, That *could* be a good start; how far away are the nearest miners outside the 4 you're thinking of deploying, and how many are there (roughly)?


Doug haynes - 1/12/2022

Hi, I am up 10 stories in a condo no obstructions overlooking hundreds of hotspots my earnings in November were .54 daily now it’s dropped 2.28 I have an eight DBI antenna what do you think the problem is


Nik - 1/12/2022

Hi Doug, it's likely that the area is just getting overcrowded. Probably not an antenna issue, though you can go with a lower gain and see what happens. I wouldn't expect a drastic change there. Most of your earnings are a derivative of your location.


MRon Cause - 1/12/2022

Hi Nik, I have a bobcat 300 with an 8dbi rak antenna about 11m high. I’m getting over 100 total witness on average over the past 5 days, 0.62 transmit scale, earnings around 12hnt per month. My question is, I see a guy 2 hexes over (smooth teal ostrich), same transmit scale, running a rakwireless, at 1.2dbi, claiming 0 meters (via explorer) and he’s getting over 17hnt in the last 30 days. He only has 75 witnesses over last 5 days. How is he getting that much with such a setup?


Nik - 1/12/2022

Hey MRon, earnings are a function of location, and a 1.2/0 assertion just means they haven't updated their details in the app yet. 2 hexes is 1,600-3,000 meters away, which can provide a significantly different coverage. After the max witness number (18) is met, earnings are a function of the quality of the witnesses, not the quantity.


Eric Thiessen - 1/12/2022

Thank you for all the info. I just bought 3 bobcats and putting them up with in a rural area. Closest other miners are about 20km away. What do you think 3 miners bouncing signals just off each other will make in a day. I am still setting things up as we speak. Can you tell me why one miner gets the normal 3 to 4 challenger rewards a day but the other only see 1 maybe 2 “challenger” rewards. Could this be internet connection related? I am Hooked to Ethernet but I can’t figure out why one isn’t getting the “challenger” as I thought this was supposed to happen roughly 3 to 4 times a day. Sync status is usually at -1. Internet is only 4mps download. However just down the road the internet is maybe 7mps and that machine is working fine. Just wondering what is cutting out my machine from getting it’s “challenger” rewards.


Nik - 1/12/2022

Hi Eric, your hotspot should challenge 1-4 times/day. Interesting that the slower connection of the two isn't challenging as much. Any way to make it faster?


Dwzcrypto - 1/21/2022

My hotspot has been online for 4 months but earning next to nothing, tried 3 different antennas, and I can see multiple hotspots near me, but only witnessed one, and they are in the same hex.


Nik - 1/21/2022

Check line of sight to the other hotspots. Antennas are probably not the problem.


Nahu Dimitri - 2/2/2022

Amazing information boss... would love to follow up (and pay for a consultation) and discuss which miners you'd suggest purchasing and how you set it up


Nik - 2/2/2022

Right on Nahu, reach out here to schedule a consult.


Jeff - 2/9/2022

Hi, I have a friend in a good sized American city (>1MM<2MM) who owns and / or manages several dozen Air BnB apartments in maybe a dozen buildings. All in a three mile square area in the hopping hip redevelopment part of downtown. Since he controls the units and the internet/wifi situation, and each of these buildings will typically have a "top floor" that is roughly as high as all the other buildings in this historic district (3-4 stories), does this seem to be an inherently promising situation for him I know nothing about existing networks or coverage in the area. Lots of tech-savvy hipsters in this part of town. I will turn him on to researching this if he would seem to have a comparative advantage perhaps worth his research and/or deployment time. (And refer him to you...) Thanks!!


Nik - 2/9/2022

Yep, probably a reasonable bet to make there. :)


Sam M. - 2/23/2022

Hi I recently purchased a senscap miner and was having a great deal of trouble getting my hotspot off of relay would you have any advice for establishing the port with an xfinity/comcast account as I am not having much help finding videos.


Nik - 2/23/2022

Hi Sam, try this workflow for getting off relay.


PCBA factory - 4/6/2022

i like it it can help me


Robert - 4/20/2022

Thanks Nik! Really great info! Question for you, I live in a 2 story house in a suburban city with many hotspots around. I’ve been using the stock 4 dbi antenna and placing mining rig in my attic with the stock antenna sitting on the window sill of the attic window. Bobcat is connected via WiFi (which is why I see the relayed status? Not sure). I have 34 witnesses but average less than .1 HNT/day. I plan on upgrading the antenna to an exterior 4 or 5.8 dbi antenna and mounting it on the roof. My question is, is it better to: A) Move the bobcat and Ethernet link it to the router on the first floor and then connect the antenna on the roof via lmr 400 cable. I would need to run about 50 feet of cable? B) Keep the bobcat linked via WiFi in the attic and connect antenna using about 10 feet of lmr 400 cable for better signal retention? C) Keep the bobcat in the attic and run an HDMI Ethernet cable to the modem along with the LMR cable (about 50 feet) to connect with the modem?


Nik - 4/20/2022

Option A sounds best.


Freewing RC Jet - 5/15/2022

thank you very much, i like the article , it can help me


Kelpie - 5/22/2022

I can put an antenna on top of the highest point in the West Midlands, UK. 360 degree line of sight as far as the horizon. Several major cities within ten miles, Inc Birmingham, Wolverhampton and more. Is it worth me looking into this?


Nik - 5/22/2022

Probably. Depends on local scaling; if there are too many Hotspots in the area it'll be hard to earn, as the majority of your earnings come from Witnessing. Check the local high and look around at the local average. I use HeliumVison for that.


Far UVC lamp - 5/23/2022

OK, IT IS good articel,thanks


bdabilisim - 6/7/2022

Icy Fiery Mule this is my device and i earn very little, i don't do my transmate scale 1 how can i increase it


King - 7/7/2022

I am a first time mining my bobcat 300 been relayed im having the most hard time in my life i need help please.


Nik - 7/8/2022

Hey mug, just be patient. Keep it connected to internet and power and just wait. It may take a week to see a change. Best to go do something else in the meantime; you're still very early in the adoption of this technology as far as blockchain + meatspace (Helium + LoRa in this case.)